View attachment 12840
Here's my list. It mostly speaks for itself.
The only Slosher that perfectly balances a fun playstyle with a decent power level, for me, is Slosher Deco. The four sloshers below it come pretty close, but fall a bit short for various reasons; mostly my not liking their specials.
Tri Nouveau and cExplo are both fine weapons, as the tier says. They can be very annoying to fight, but they're genuinely fun to play.
I don't actually hate Dread D, it's just that they could have given it any other kit and it would have been better off. I do hate vBlob, though; the reason I don't like vSlosher as much as Slosher Deco because I feel like it plays too passively. Imagine how I feel about Blob. I slightly prefer its Kraken kit for similar reason.
Lastly, vTri is awkward and vExplo is also very passive.
I generally prefer midline sloshers, especially those with good tools to deal with long range threats. I really hope Bloblobber eventually gets a rework to make it play more aggressively; if not for its issues, it would probably be my favorite slosher.