Lol the war of the admins. x)
I feel like it's too early to base conclusions on which games/genres the rulesets should be based off of at all. For example, MK's standard ruleset for wars uses the total points of a team to determine it a win or a loss, which I guess could also be done in Splatoon. Or if we use the smash/shooter method of counting W/L to determine the winner, which would be another method. However, I agree with Agosta in the fact that the community is not structured enough to do rulesets that are used in games that mainly are played offline competitively. Splatoon has to have an online based community before it can have an offline one. I think you guys are simply misunderstanding each other in ways as you guys have repeated each others' reasoning.
I feel like it's too early to base conclusions on which games/genres the rulesets should be based off of at all. For example, MK's standard ruleset for wars uses the total points of a team to determine it a win or a loss, which I guess could also be done in Splatoon. Or if we use the smash/shooter method of counting W/L to determine the winner, which would be another method. However, I agree with Agosta in the fact that the community is not structured enough to do rulesets that are used in games that mainly are played offline competitively. Splatoon has to have an online based community before it can have an offline one. I think you guys are simply misunderstanding each other in ways as you guys have repeated each others' reasoning.
I think both TheRapture and Agosta clearly realize this. Agosta is meaning to say that he likes the system of having clan wars in mario kart be completely open AND competitive, and can be played competitively by using any method.I believe they're saying they don't understand why you'd model Splatoon's competitive scene off of MK's when MK is a completely different genre than Splatoon (racing game vs third person shooter). Competitive shooters would be a closer comparison since it's only a jump from first to third person rather than going completely across genre lines.