DekuKitty
Pro Squid
The salt in this thread is real.
That is a false equivalent actually, Squidbagging can and does have multiple meanings and uses while teabagging only has one. Typically in those games voice chat and taunts are also a thing so the need to convert a action in a game to catch all is not necessary. This is the same with flipping the bird, there is only one meaning for it (depending on your culture) and its hard to actually take it another way. Using a situation with friends is more of a 'context matters' argument and not a 'its always bad' one. I'm sure you're familiar with the thumbs up action, in the west it is a innocent and positive thing but in certain countries a thumbs up gesture is the same as a extremely rude one. If I came across someone who identified the thumbs up as negative and rude and didn't like it should I be required to stop using the action? I could to be nice to them and comply but they could also return the favor and realize that I am not using it in that way and leave me be.@Kayura05
You keep telling us to give "squidbaggers" the "benefit of the doubt", as if that would somehow remedy the trauma of its sister act. Yes, context is a very important factor, but so are relations. If your friend flipped you the bird you would probably either chuckle, shrug it off or return the favour. If a stranger flips you the bird, would you react the same way? The act is historically vulgar and the way we perceive it depends on who's doing it. To those who are bothered by teabagging, "squidbagging" is like the equivalent of having a stranger flip them the bird, which is the point I'm trying to get across. I am not looking to cease the act because 1) I know it's not going to happen, and 2) other people clearly have a new and different perception of the act.
See, what irks me is how people seem to dismiss those bothered by it as either stuck up, overly sensitive, or as you were implying, presumptious. That's not the point. The point is that it is a matter of perception, and we have a very bad history associated with ours. I'm not here to cause a revolt, only to make it clear where we are coming from. It would be nice if we weren't simply dismissed for having a negative viewpoint. As I said earlier, if you aren't bothered by it, then good for you. I'm not trying to change that. Only to make you aware of why some are.
Splatoon is, as I'm sure you're aware, a new game, where the "crouch" is entirelly different in both function and animation to any other shooter, but the new "meaning" of squidbagging came to be after its inception. To many newcomers and veterans alike, we recognise the act as teabagging from other games of its genre. Why? Because 1) entering squid-form is basically crouching - your hitbox lowers - with a few mechanical differences, and 2) this is a shooter, just like the other games where the act has been recorded.new and different perception of the act.
Lack of voice chat is very relevant, it means we don't have a traditional means of communication and have to get creative. Squidbagging is one of those ways. There is no one way to interpret it, so limiting it to being only negative is a flawed way of thinking. This isn't a conversation with a real person where subtly can play any sort of role. I agree to take a step back though.@Kayura05
First of all, the presence or absence of voice chat here is irrelevant, regardless of its influence on the act of teabagging in its inception, or squidbagging as of now. You may also say that in-game actions aren't meant to harm anyone, but humans have their own brilliant ways of attaching hidden messages to subtle things. This is beyond the control of you and I as individuals, but groups have already established these things for us whether we agree with it or not.
And second, actually, no. It is rather fitting. Let's take a step back here.
I understand that but again the association is on your part, and to a degree I see it as that at times too. Well inasmuch as I see it as a taunt or tease. Although knowing not everyone else sees it as that serious I have more than a little leeway in when and where I use it.Prior to Splatoon, teabagging had and still has one negative message attached to it. Transitioning into Splatoon, given entering squid form is the closest thing we have to a crouch in the game it is no wonder how some would immediately associate repeated "crouches" as teabagging. If I may speak from personal experience, this is precisely how I saw squidbagging being used at the start and, albeit to a lesser extent, still do.
I don't think I would take it that far, when I first saw someone mention it I didn't give it much thought as its not really a 1:1 comparison really.Splatoon is, as I'm sure you're aware, a new game, where the "crouch" is entirelly different in both function and animation to any other shooter, but the new "meaning" of squidbagging came to be after its inception. To many newcomers and veterans alike, we recognise the act as teabagging from other games of its genre. Why? Because 1) entering squid-form is basically crouching - your hitbox lowers - with a few mechanical differences, and 2) this is a shooter, just like the other games where the act has been recorded.
The solution there would be to realize not everyone sees it the same way and judge situations based on context. Imagine if a American, European, and Japanese player were to squidbag you. Do you think the act would mean the same thing from each player? I mean it could but ya know what I mean. :) Good example about player migration that does make sense.To use your comparison of ethnicity, Splatoon is the country where the "thumbs up" is regarded as a positive, but everyone who migrated from different shooters - or countries - know the "thumbs up" as a rude gesture.
I basically agree except that I find the interpretation VERY deniable, but hey that's opinions for you.I will concede that in the above example it is difficult to ascertain which interpretation was conceived first, but that is irrelevant. Now, back to my comparison in my previous post, squidbagging is just that. It is a historically rude gesture with one meaning. However, Splatoon has invented a different "meaning" for the act, either due to sheer comical value or that players simply couldn't recognise it as teabagging from its animation, but after examination the similarities are undeniably clear.
Yeah I understand that, which is why I feel that the context argument is the best. So yeah we can lay the issue to rest.And for the last time, I am not seeking a change. All I seek is understanding. If your recognise that, then I would like to put this case to rest before I turn into a broken record. This thread is for discussing and sharing viewpoints as I understand it, not advocating for or against the abolishment of squidbagging.