Marigi174
Inkster Jr.
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2015
- Messages
- 23
- NNID
- Marigi174
I'm a hypocrite. This is a wall of text.
OK. I've spent the past 40 or so minutes re-reading (mostly skimming tbh) and this is what is going through my head atm.
Town: Bruce Squillis
Null: Bossanova, African American, xCoCo
Null-Scum: JeXs, h.JC, Drez
Possible Scum: Squid Master
OK. Here is my thought process:
Bruce Squillis isn't suspicious at all, and I get the feeling that he is a townie based around his activity in the thread, and it feels like he has a genuine concern about finding who is mafia.
I am leaning more towards town with Bossanova atm. He generally has a lot of substance to his posts, and from what I can see a lot of why people are considering him as possible scum is the result of what I think are mostly coincidences. I can't really find any solid evidence towards scum, but I don't feel that I have enough data to put him in town.
I barely have any data to make any conclusions around African American, so he is null. From the way he has been posting though he is a town lean as, from what he's posted so far, there has been nothing to arouse suspicion.
xCoCo is a fuzzy area for me. Your jokes in the early stages of the thread could suggest suspicion, but idk what I could take from it due to the possibility that they could be genuine jokes or jokes designed to mess with our heads. I can't say that I am leaning in either direction for you.
I don't really have much data to go off of for JeXs. He/she (sorry idk ur gender ;;;) seems to be showing the same passive nature as he explained early-on, but your lack of aggression so far despite saying that you push your suspicions aggressively is enough for me to be slightly suspicious. You have a foot in null, but you feel slightly more null-scum atm based around my gut.
h.JC is partly based around the way that Squid jumped onto you saying your "official announcement" to specify that he was town, which could imply that you are both scummy and he, knowing this, was trying to mess with our heads to throw us off of the scent at a very early stage of day 1 in order to minimise the chance of you being seen as suspicious. However, you aren't a particularly strong read for me, and you do have a foot in null (just like JeXs).
With Drez, I am not completely convinced about your position yet. A lot of this is due to me still being very slightly suspicious from a few pages back with your ultimatum against h.JC. However, I am not sure whether you are scum or not due to the possibility of it just being your personality shining through, and as a result you are like the rest of null-scum in that you have a foot in null and are only a slight lean.
Something about Squid Master makes me uncomfortable. While he hasn't been very active, I feel like when I look at the way that he has been going about his patterns of activity are dubious. I mean, lemme just go over all of Squid's posts and show you what I mean:
Also, according to his profile, he was on around midday yesterday. He even posted in another thread (link to post is here). If that's the case, why didn't he reply to the thread? Was there not a big enough of a bandwagon for him to ride? I'm not that convinced that his inactivity was just due to him being busy. (Sorry; I know people keep saying that inactivity isn't that good of an indicator, but I couldn't leave out a detail like that.)
Overall, I am more convinced about Squid Master atm than I am about anyone else due to what I can make out from his posting patterns.
##vote: Squid Master
OK. I've spent the past 40 or so minutes re-reading (mostly skimming tbh) and this is what is going through my head atm.
Town: Bruce Squillis
Null: Bossanova, African American, xCoCo
Null-Scum: JeXs, h.JC, Drez
Possible Scum: Squid Master
OK. Here is my thought process:
Bruce Squillis isn't suspicious at all, and I get the feeling that he is a townie based around his activity in the thread, and it feels like he has a genuine concern about finding who is mafia.
I am leaning more towards town with Bossanova atm. He generally has a lot of substance to his posts, and from what I can see a lot of why people are considering him as possible scum is the result of what I think are mostly coincidences. I can't really find any solid evidence towards scum, but I don't feel that I have enough data to put him in town.
I barely have any data to make any conclusions around African American, so he is null. From the way he has been posting though he is a town lean as, from what he's posted so far, there has been nothing to arouse suspicion.
xCoCo is a fuzzy area for me. Your jokes in the early stages of the thread could suggest suspicion, but idk what I could take from it due to the possibility that they could be genuine jokes or jokes designed to mess with our heads. I can't say that I am leaning in either direction for you.
I don't really have much data to go off of for JeXs. He/she (sorry idk ur gender ;;;) seems to be showing the same passive nature as he explained early-on, but your lack of aggression so far despite saying that you push your suspicions aggressively is enough for me to be slightly suspicious. You have a foot in null, but you feel slightly more null-scum atm based around my gut.
h.JC is partly based around the way that Squid jumped onto you saying your "official announcement" to specify that he was town, which could imply that you are both scummy and he, knowing this, was trying to mess with our heads to throw us off of the scent at a very early stage of day 1 in order to minimise the chance of you being seen as suspicious. However, you aren't a particularly strong read for me, and you do have a foot in null (just like JeXs).
With Drez, I am not completely convinced about your position yet. A lot of this is due to me still being very slightly suspicious from a few pages back with your ultimatum against h.JC. However, I am not sure whether you are scum or not due to the possibility of it just being your personality shining through, and as a result you are like the rest of null-scum in that you have a foot in null and are only a slight lean.
Something about Squid Master makes me uncomfortable. While he hasn't been very active, I feel like when I look at the way that he has been going about his patterns of activity are dubious. I mean, lemme just go over all of Squid's posts and show you what I mean:
What was the point of this post? He is the only person who did this, and the fact that he is stating this implies a role in which he has some power. Slightly suspicious.
Joke vote. Maybe messing with our heads, but unlikely.
He is promoting the use of RVS. This is somewhat tentative, but there is a small possibility that it may be to direct attention away from himself or to promote the idea of not analysing posts on day 1, minimising his chance of becoming suspicious. Small increase in suspicion.
Once again, what was the point of this post? Seriously, him insisting on stating anything about his position is raising my suspicion, and tbh the fact that he is insisting that he is town is not exactly helping his cause as it just looks like scum trying to fit in with the townies. Raising my suspicion.
Answering a question. Not suspicious.
Why didn't he unvote Bruce in his previous post? What was the point answering it only to state his viewpoint on Bruce again three minutes later and unvote in a different post? It is dubious, but the suspicion it raises is small.
Neutral statement in response to why he jumped offline again. Not suspicious.
Is this meant to be a question? The question mark implies it, and somehow I don't think that was a typo because you need to press shift in order to write one while the button is not next to any notable punctuation that needs to have shift pressed in order to work. If its on a phone, question mark is not next to a full stop (or period for you 'murricans) on any major brands, which means that it is unlikely that it was meant to be a full stop. This implies that he is trying to go with the opinions of someone else, which implies that he is scummy due to a lack of willingness to make his own reads.
This post is very vague, but that is understandable at an early point in the game. However, if compared with the previous post quoted, it is once again implicative that he doesn't want to make reads for fear of being caught. Slightly suspicious.
"Gut feeling" is once again implying that he doesn't want to make reads. It certainly isn't helping his cause and it makes him look like he just wants to go with the crowd if the suspicious attention isn't directed at him. Kind of suspicious.
Why is he trying to force a vote with over 36 hours left? Considering his previous passiveness, this is VERY abrupt and feels a lot like he wants to find a bandwagon to ride. This is implying that he REALLY doesn't want to make any suspicious posts.
Confusion after he ninja'd JeXs. No suspicion.
Linking these two posts because they tie into one another. The fact that he is pushing for a vote now and voting Bossanova for activity/to prevent a modkill is almost as if he is trying to pin mafia onto an inactive user. In addition to this, the fact that he even states that he just wanted to start a wagon implies that he REALLY doesn't want attention. Its suspicious in my eyes.
No substance, no suspicion.
Overall, I am more convinced about Squid Master atm than I am about anyone else due to what I can make out from his posting patterns.
##vote: Squid Master
