I came here to post a poll thread about "when do you change lobbies?" and found this thread already here. Great squiddy minds think alike!
I find it interesting to see a lot of very good players do quite the opposite. On my main account I tended to stick with a lobby until it became really bad, but then started changing lobbies every match. On my alt, I raised it from Cflat to B+ in a single lobby/rotation (or 2, there might have been a disconnect in between), but B+ took 2-3 sessions, and back in the A's, I've returned to leaving the lobby every match for the most part.
I do tend to stick with the same lobby if both teams seem well matched and end up finishing in a very tight match as I can assume the possibility that I'm the difference between win and loss (especially as an alt) in these matches between two otherwise equally good teams and can keep the win streak going with any mix of players. But VERY rarely does the matchmaker give me that luxury. I'm forever cursed with weak teams against strong teams, and if I stay with a lobby after a win I seem likely to be given the weak players from the other team after the good players from my team leave, while, if I stay in the lobby after a loss, I'll keep getting the same weak players who seem to think I can carry them (I can't.) Like others said, these matches that end in a KO in under a minute I bail win or lose. Last night in TC, almost every single match was a 25 second KO. Even with different lobbies sometimes it was my team, sometimes it was the other. But no match lasted longer than a minute. I just stopped playing while I was ahead. Some matches I'm against a super player I don't want to deal with again, others I have 3 teammates who do not touch the objective (or worse, grab it instantly and do nothing with it.)
I've sometimes considered the bad matchmaking might be "punishing" me for switching lobbies too often. I'm glad to see some S+'s that haven't experienced that - it's just me! (yay?)
So I've been wondering, myself, whether others switch lobbies every match, or only when they lose, or only when they win, or never unless they're weapon switching.
for S/S+ I may change rooms if it looks like people are adopting to my play style and countering it.
I've often considered this, and I'm glad I'm not alone. Especially for players of more short range/specialty weapons (and chargers) there's going to be patterns, map techniques etc that you have to use to your advantage, and playing against the same players, or, worse, playing against your former teammates gives them way too much knowledge about your practiced strategies for weapons that require stealth and positioning. Mid-range shooters don't really have that problem.
It's a shame it doesn't work like splatfest where you can stick with your same team if they work well with you, and keep getting new random enemies to play against rather than just shuffling around the same lobby and throwing random players in.