Mafia 3 | Game OVER! Who won?!

[Drez]

Thingy, it's very telling when I swing a wagon from you to Rom that you are suddenly not emotional, and suddenly these insults come at me whenever I accuse you.

But tell me, who is scum today?

 

[Thingyman]

Also, African American is known to create red herring setups, so consider that fact in mind. I wouldn't put it past him to give no power roles. Jailer is a great role for mafia to fake claim, in a town that has almost no activity (and most likely no power roles). Especially since Boo never spoke about it to say that he suspected me.

That is my thoughts on the setup considering that we mass claimed. I can go more into Thingy/Boo interactions in a bit.

Like, I won't even bother replying to you anymore...

I'll ask everyone else: Do you think me and Boo are a team? Really?

 

[ReedRGale]

Alright, just got back in here for massive explostion of activity. Wonderful! Alright, lemme compile my thoughts. Wow posts are flooding in as I type. I better hop in quick.

 

[Thingyman]

Thingy, it's very telling when I swing a wagon from you to Rom that you are suddenly not emotional, and suddenly these insults come at me whenever I accuse you.

But tell me, who is scum today?

It is?

What is it telling of?

Do enlighten me into the psychology of people. Tell me how townies never react defensively or emotionally if pressured. Do tell.

 

[Drez]

Thingy, who is scum to you toDay?

 

[Thingyman]

Alright, just got back in here for massive explostion of activity. Wonderful! Alright, lemme compile my thoughts. Wow posts are flooding in as I type. I better hop in quick.

Reed

I really think you are town

With Drez spazzing out I'll move him to null, since who the hell knows, it seems I may just kind of have to hope that he's scum here.

But for real, Reed, you can tell this to everyone: In the last game, you and I were scum together. What did I immediately say should be the strategy for LYLO? Was it to claim or to "avoid thread and try to avoid claiming"?

Drez is spinning a narrative where me being AFK (again, I've been AFK in other games as well - was I trying to cower away from claiming in those as well? means that I was trying to avoid having to claim. Be honest - does that seem in line with your image of me from last game?

 

[Drez]

Yeah, Thingy is scum stuck in a corner, trying to appeal to others.

 

[Thingyman]

Thingy, who is scum to you toDay?

You mean who has made scummy posts during this day phase?

I dunno, no one. Maybe Boo, but his posts are probably just null.

I don't read people this way. I read people like this: I take those I think are townies and I remove them from the pile. Then I vote someone out of the rest who I can't say has posted anything townie. So when I'm voting someone and pushing for their lynch, it's not necessarily that they're scummy - it's that they haven't been townie.

 

[Thingyman]

You mean who has made scummy posts during this day phase?

I dunno, no one. Maybe Boo, but his posts are probably just null.

I don't read people this way. I read people like this: I take those I think are townies and I remove them from the pile. Then I vote someone out of the rest who I can't say has posted anything townie. So when I'm voting someone and pushing for their lynch, it's not necessarily that they're scummy - it's that they haven't been townie.

And Drez will reply to this in the following manner: "Omg, look at Thingy, he can't say any scum leans".

But that's not what he asked me.

 

[Drez]

I don't read people this way. I read people like this: I take those I think are townies and I remove them from the pile. Then I vote someone out of the rest who I can't say has posted anything townie. So when I'm voting someone and pushing for their lynch, it's not necessarily that they're scummy - it's that they haven't been townie.

That's stupid.

 

[xCoCo]

One thing, is that in a game of mostly (seemingly) vanilla townies, it's odd that there is only one power role. Also, in a game of actual no power roles, it would make sense that scum would no kill to insinuate lurkers as scum. (Slaking1 and lonelysquid, who both flipped vt)

This makes Boo's double action on me as trying to set me up (the most obv town), while Thingy takes the fall.

Consider this. Thingy was never proactive with Boo, only until I called him out. Then he straight tunneled Boo as if he really believed it.

Today, we lynch Thingy. Tomorrow, Boo. I understand people will be confused about this, but talk to me and I can show you why it's the most likely team.

Unless a PR claimed vanilla townie - which I don't think is likely, but they could be scared
But I'll be honest I dont know enough about setups to know whether a PR has been tossed in here or not.
It is likely that mafia could have no killeld and Boo could keep claiming that he jailed Drez.

Just like it's also possible Drez could have been targeted - and Boo could have saved him, or could have blocked Mafia.
But then why wouldn't mafia switch the person making the kill? Why wouldn't they change their target and not for for Drez night two?
It sounds like a team of newbie scum - considering how great Thingy is - I don't know if he would make those type of mistakes.

 

[Thingyman]

Yeah, Thingy is scum stuck in a corner, trying to appeal to others.

Your case on me is:

1. I am scum with Boo.

This is ... I just don't even have the words. I will let everyone else judge this.

2. I avoided thread on purpose to avoid claiming.

What could I possibly gain from this? Why would I do this?

It is not something I do as scum, Reed can confirm. And there is no benefit to it. When EVERYONE is calling for me to claim and I don't claim, do you think that's a good way for a scum to avoid attention?

So again, I ask everyone else. What do you find more likely: That I am scum and saw that people wanted me to claim and said "nah", I'll hold off. Or that I was just legitimately AFK?

You should've checked my "last checkec forum" or something if you can do that, before I started posting today.

 

[Thingyman]

That's stupid.

yeah

alright, dude

have fun

if we lose, this is all on you (if you're townie)

 

[Drez]

It's not possible that I was targetted twice. Scum wouldn't be dumb to target me twice after failing once already.

 

[xCoCo]

Not going to lie this is so tense

 

[Drez]

It sounds like a team of newbie scum - considering how great Thingy is - I don't know if he would make those type of mistakes.

That's my point. The 'newbie scum' should have been lonely squid and slaking 1 because of the possibility of not being online to send in the kill, which them flipping vts shows that it was just done that way to frame them. It's not newbie scum due to that.

Either way, Thingy is the best lynch toDay for scum #1.

 

[xCoCo]

I would like to hear Reed's read on 'Korn.

 

[Thingyman]

That's my point. The 'newbie scum' should have been lonely squid and slaking 1 because of the possibility of not being online to send in the kill, which them flipping vts shows that it was just done that way to frame them. It's not newbie scum due to that.

Either way, Thingy is the best lynch toDay for scum #1.

I really hope you are town. I really do.

What will your reaction be? Just assume I'll flip town, what's your excuse?

 

[Drez]

Sure thing. How are you reading Thingy at the moment?

 

[ReedRGale]

chill guys im making my trademark longpost in a sec xD

get some tea or something