1. Consider this is the last day to get it correct. Lynching me would lose the game for town. Mafia pulling out the stops is there best chance at victory toDay.
2. Consider that, a jailer in a town with no other town role, is odd. It's also a great role to fake-claim.
3. Boo never outright claimed it to point out to possible scum, but instead was claiming to appear town. (When you get a block on someone twice, you claim that to get a scum lynch)
4. It's scums best chance to claim two blocks on the most obvious townie, especially when he is most likely right.
Thank the stars that you actually are logical. So let me break this down:
Point 1: Yes, it is. So it is imperative that we pick whoever is the most likely choice of scum. This point only holds should we work on the assumption that you are town, which I'll admit, I had been looking from until this point in the game.
Point 2: This is true and your strongest point. It
is weird that there's a town with only one jailer.
...Yet I can think of no other reasonable explanation for no death on night two: there
had to be a power player. We were all active participants at that point and if there's a mafia out there (which it would be hilarious and trollish [and a terrible thing to do to us AA] if this was a game with no scum) which means someone had to be blocked in some way. Seeing as there are no other roleclaims, I'd say his is pretty legit...
...though I'll admit, he was pretty eager to get out there and say it. Still, I refuse to believe the "no kill choice" thing two nights in a row.
Point 3: That, I think, is just his inexperience shining and not a valid point.
Point 4: Now that's true. You are the most obvious townie. Ughh... I dunno. I wanna trust my gut and just go with Thingy, but my reasoning is pointing me at you.
Can you answer this question, please: what other reasonable explanation is there for no death at night? Do you think there isn't a mafia to begin with and we're all being played by AA? The mafia had a choice between a power-role and killing or something similar to that logic? Is someone hiding their role stupidly at the LYLO phase? None of it seems
reasonable.
Just tell me some other logical thought process I can latch onto. :l You don't seem like a sure mafia but at the same time, you seem like the most probable just considering the information at hand.
You have to look at Boo's motivations for choosing to block me twice in a row. If I were a pr, he could have blocked me from doing anything while being a town read. Finally, you have to see if you can read Boo as town or scum, before looking at his claim.
Thingy is still the best lynch ToDay. I suggest you re-read the thread to see if I am playing like scum before you consider to lock down your vote on me. I also suggest to look at Thingy's play, and Boo's play.
That's the
thing! I don't think you're playing like scum. But I know you're intelligent and can make it look like you're playing as town when really... ughhh Thingy's capabilities last game have put me on edge. Honestly, as things go, I've agreed with your read on Bool from the start--he seems null-scum to me because his actions point toward inactive and "post just enough." The roleclaim that he has just baffles me.
But it's the only explanation I can see, gameplay-mechanics considered for no deaths two nights in a row. Aykorn's logic might apply and the mafia aimed for you twice in a row but... you yourself stated that's unlikely. To psych us out? To set up that line of thought?
You seem townie. Ughhh... please give me another line of reasoning so I can continue my breakdown of Thingy as most scummy. ._.
No night kills: that's the lynchpin that locks this argument in my mind. If you can provide another logical explanation that is probable, I'll unvote. But not until.
Now. Talk to me about Boo. You straight scumread him all game. You haven't commented on his claim or his targets, you just defended yourself alot.
If I recall correctly, this has been the question all game. And I think he said that he was just pushing him in the beginning to get him to post... but he did it in a flippant manner--not his playstyle and odd to me. Did he continue pushing him day two? I forget.